alternative market--treasure chest or Pandora's box for agents
In the last quarter century, a record number of organizations have chosen to finance risk in a non-traditional way. The result is that over 30% of commercial insurance is in the alternative marketplace. It would seem to some observers that the alphabet houses (Marsh & McLennan, Johnson & Higgins, etc.) have discovered this marketplace to be a "treasure chest." Unfortunately, many independent agents view this same market to be "Pandora's Box" -- if you keep the lid on tight, the problems won't be seen or have to be dealt with.
The purpose of this article is to assist agents in understanding how the alternative market can be a treasure chest which will: increase the retention of customers; bring in new customers; increase revenues and profit; make the agency more dynamic.
One of the most significant challenges to traditional insurance and to independent, local agents came in the mid-'80s. Public entities quite suddenly found themselves having to cancel fireworks and festivals, and close skating rinks and playgrounds they had been using for years because insurers refused to cover the liability exposure. How municipalities reacted to this dilemma is an important piece of the history of the alternative marketplace.
They created municipal association pools--i.e., they told the traditional market, "We want what we need, not what you want to give us." The exodus created by these public entity pools has stunned many agents who wrote public entity business throughout their agency's existence. In some cases, agents were taught at seminars how to sell against the pools; they could talk to their public entity prospects about the pool's lack of track record; its joint and several liability; future assessments; and lack of underwriting.
In spite of this, municipal pools have thrived over the last 10 years. If you look hard, you will find a handful of agents who viewed the challenge posed by insurers' refusal to write liability insurance as an opportunity to assist local groups in creating alternatives. Today, many of those agents continue to provide services to the pools they helped create.
Let's explore what we mean by the alternative marketplace:
* high retention/deductible programs
* retrospectively rated plans
* captives (group, association, renta-captive)
* pools/trusts
* self-insurance groups (WC only)
* producer-owned insurance companies
High retention/deductible plans.
Every insurance program should be structured in a manner which takes into account the organization's ability to self-fund some risks. This should not be viewed as reducing premium/commission income; rather, it is reallocating of funds used to cover risk.
(Note: A number of agents disclose all income derived from a particular client to that client and add service fees to those policies which are priced net of commission, or with commissions inappropriately low based on agent's time required to service.)
The institution or corporation with the highest levels of self-funded risk can best weather the cyclical vagaries of the insurance marketplace.
Retrospectively rated plans. A few agents seek retros--particularly, unusually funded retros--from their market sources to have available as the need arises with a particular client.
Recently, the CFO of a local manufacturer went to his agent looking for some better way to fund workers compensation than through the assigned risk plan. The annual premium was $325,000. The agent indicated that none of his carriers were interested in writing the business on a voluntary basis--thus, the Assigned Risk was the only option. A short time later, this CFO was introduced to an insurance agent at a school fundraiser. He was grousing about the problem and this agent gave him his business card with the usual "call me." The result, provided by a very small insurance agency, was a retrospectively rated plan which, based on historic loss information (trended and developed) would save the manufacturer $30,000 to $90,000 a year. The agent requested the opportunity to quote on the rest of the business, and, the rest is history.
Be prepared. It works for the Boy Scouts, and works even better for insurance agents.
Captives. Generally, a captive is defined as "a closely held insurance company whose insurance business is primarily supplied by and controlled by its owners, and, in which the original insureds are the principal beneficiaries."1
Agents can direct clients toward captives which are in operation today. An example would be a local agent insuring the local rural electric cooperative (REA) That agent might get a quote from Federated, a Wisconsin domiciled captive which insures REAs. The agent might find broader coverage at a lower cost than the traditional market.
Most captives which insure U.S. organizations are domiciled (regulated) in Bermuda or Vermont, although several other on- and off-shore domiciles license captives.
Labels: alternative market, treasure chest or Pandora's box for agents
